Grilled Peanut Butter, Mango & Peach Sandwiches

A brand new take on an old classic! Grown up PB&J, grilled with fresh fruit and drizzled in honey!!

I’m on a peanut butter kick.

Lately I’ve been eating peanut butter every single day and in every possible way. I don’t know what it is but it just always sounds good.  Sometimes I’m in the mood for chicken or maybe something sour, other days not so much.

But it seems like these days I’m always in the mood for peanut butter.

And by these days I mean the past several months. So maybe I should say these months I’m always in the mood for peanut butter.

It’s only been in recent years that I’ve really honed in on my peanut butter love. Growing up I could do without it.

Other than your traditional peanut butter and jelly sandwich, I really never had much peanut butter. Now my next-door neighbor/best friend? She could put that peanut butter away. And I mean by the spoonful. Straight from the jar. Like I said, I only had it on peanut butter and jelly sandwiches.

This sandwich is like a fancy shmancy grown-up PB&J. I still love the traditional version, (with cheetos! childhood quirk) but a while back I started putting fresh fruit on my sandwiches instead of jam or jelly and I am absolutely hooked.

I actually can’t remember the last time I actually put jelly on my peanut butter sandwiches. I’ve tried loads of combinations of fresh fruit and jelly usually just doesn’t sound as good to me any more. I really have tried quite a few. Apples, strawberries, pears… This one though. Mango, white peach, and honey…  It’s my all-time favorite.

At least til I find a new winning combo. But this one will be really, really hard to beat. The peaches and mangos give the whole sandwich sort of a summery, tropical twist which I am really loving at the moment as it’s now August (What??!) and summer sadly will be drawing to a close before we know it…

(But lets pretend for now that it isn’t. )

And then the bread gets a little crispy and the peanut butter becomes all melty gooey from the grilling…. Peanut butter sandwich heaven.

A little drizzle (or large drizzle) of honey is the perfect way to top it all off. Like wrapping it all in a pretty bow. If you’re not a honey person, leave it off. If i’m in a rush I’ll skip it and it’s still delicious. But if you are a honey person, or even if you just have no preference and can’t decide if it’s worth the effort, do the honey. It’s amazing.

I almost feel strange posting this because it’s so dang easy and it’s so simple. But it’s so good it needs to be shared. And we all eat lunch every day right? So we could all use a new way to dress up our go-to PB&Js. Try this next time you’re fixing yourself a sandwich. Its absolutely amazing. Even if it only takes two seconds and requires no skill. That just makes it even better!

Print Pin
4 from 1 vote

Grilled Peanut Butter & Mango Peach Sandwiches

A brand new take on an old classic! Grown up PB&J, grilled with fresh fruit and drizzled in honey!!
Course Main Course
Keyword grilled, mango, peanut butter
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 5 minutes
Total Time 10 minutes
Servings 4
Author Tiffany


  • 8 slices whole wheat or multigrain bread
  • 8 tablespoons peanut butter
  • 1 large peach (white or yellow), peeled and thinly sliced
  • 1 large mango, peeled and thinly sliced
  • 4 tablespoons honey


  • Preheat grill (or George Foreman which works spectacularly). Spread about 2 tablespoons of peanut butter on each slice of bread. Layer mango and peach slices on top of peanut butter on four slices of bread.
  •  Top fruit slices with remaining slices of bread, peanut butter side down. Grill 2-3 minutes. Drizzle with honey and serve warm. Enjoy!


Share The Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


This sounds yummy!! What a great combination 🙂

Wow, I never would have expected this combo would be good but I definitely trust you! 🙂 Beautiful photos! And simple recipes are wonderful, especially when it’s an ingenious flavor combo you have created. 🙂

    Simply + delicious = major win. Thank you so much Erin, I’m so flattered to hear such sweet comments on my recipes and photos!

This sandwich looks incredibly good, it must be a killer combination indeed! And your pictures are beautiful, I love them 🙂

I go through peanut butter phases myself. I have been known to find myself standing at the fridge eating it right out of the jar! This looks so delicious.

    I hear you. I never fall out of love with peanut butter but sometimes I just crave it like crazy!! Thanks Katie!

Amazing! I could use peanut butter on any kind of grilled cheese!

Oh my geeee…this looks delictable! Loving your photography! Think I found what I making for lunch!

4 stars
Please follow the diet plan.

I no longer have a grill. Any way to make this in a toaster oven or microwave??

    I definitely don’t recommend using a microwave- I’m afraid it will come out too soft/mushy. You could try a toaster oven? I can’t say for sure on that one as I haven’t tried that method myself for this recipe!

Discover New Recipes