Brown Sugar Bourbon Chicken & Mushroom Melt

A simple marinade turns this brown sugar bourbon chicken & mushroom melt into a hearty and flavorful sandwich you’ll put on repeat on summer long! 

Brown Sugar Bourbon Chicken & Mushroom Melt |

This right here, is what summer is all about. I mean, yes it’s about the flip flops and drippy popsicles and tanlines (you should see my baby boy’s farmer’s tan, it is real nice…) but apart from the family summertime activities, summer grilling just might be the thing I look forward to the most.

Brown Sugar Bourbon Chicken & Mushroom Melt |

When people find out that I cook A LOT – even when they don’t know I’m a food blogger – they almost always ask me this question… “what is something really easy and delicious I can whip up when I get home from work??” And when I blush a little and say dump some marinade in a bag with some chicken and then grill it up, their minds are blown like it had never occurred to them do that and I’m sitting here thinking really??!? We LIVE on marinated grilled chicken in the summertime. Well all year round really. But especially in the warmer months.

Brown Sugar Bourbon Chicken & Mushroom Melt |

This is my most recent marinated-chicken-dinner-recipe and I instantly fell in love with the big bold flavors from this new Grill Mates Brown Sugar Bourbon Single Use Marinade. The whole sandwich came together and it was like heaven in my mouth. Even my husband kept saying how amazing it was. And then it hit me that instead of grilling burgers for our family 4th of July party, let’s do these Brown Sugar Bourbon Chicken & Mushroom Melts instead!!! The husband was on board and the rest is history. These beauties are on the menu and there’s no going back now.

Brown Sugar Bourbon Chicken & Mushroom Melt |

We are heading to the Oregon coast right after July 4th with my in laws for a family vacay and I am ridiculously excited for a whole week in a house on the beach. We divided up dinner responsibilities per family, like we usually do, and I called dibs on burgers right off the bat but we ditched that plan after trying these sandwiches – they’re just too good not to be shared, and way too good not to have on REPEAT for the rest of the summer.

Brown Sugar Bourbon Chicken & Mushroom Melt |

And that big, bold flavored marinade we just discussed? It only needs thirty minutes in a bag with some chicken to work it’s big, bold flavor magic. Gosh I just love that. AND and and – it comes in a single use packet so you can throw it away after and not have to worry about messing with sticky bottles (gasp!) It’s like they made it just for my Oregon trip. I feel like I owe a big fat THANK YOU to the Grill Mates single use marinade packaging designers for giving me one less thing to worry about when I’m packing for and stressing about transporting two 9-month old kidlets across several states.

Brown Sugar Bourbon Chicken & Mushroom Melt |

Besides the chicken, all you need to whip up these tasty sammies are some soft rolls (I love brioche, but use your fav!), lettuce, mayo (optional), mushrooms sautéed in a little garlic butter, and smoked mozzarella cheese. And that’s it! (insert fist bump here) Let the marinade and your grill do all the work this 4th of July and enjoy a fun and stress-free holiday with the peeps you call friends and family.

Let freedom ring and please let it taste like a brown sugar bourbon chicken & mushroom melt.

Brown Sugar Bourbon Chicken & Mushroom Melt |

Brown Sugar Bourbon Chicken & Mushroom Melt

A simple marinade turns this brown sugar bourbon chicken & mushroom melt into a hearty and flavorful sandwich you'll put on repeat on summer long!

Course Main Course
Cuisine American
Keyword Chicken, melt, sandwich
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 20 minutes
Marinading Time 30 minutes
Total Time 25 minutes
Servings 4
Author Tiffany



  1. Place chicken in a large resealable bag along with contents of the marinade packet. Seal and refrigerate for 30 minutes.

  2. Grease and preheat your grill. Place chicken on the grill and discard marinade. Cook chicken 6-8 minutes one each side until cooked through.

  3. While chicken is grilling, prepare the mushrooms. Melt butter in a medium pan. Add mushrooms and garlic and saute over medium heat 2-4 minutes until mushrooms are tender and garlic is fragrant.

  4. Spoon some of the mushrooms onto each of the chicken breasts. Top with 1 or 2 slices of cheese, cover grill until cheese is melty (1-2 minutes).

  5. Slice your rolls/buns and assemble your sandwiches by first spreading mayo onto the bottom half of the rolls, then topping with lettuce, chicken, and top of roll. Serve immediately.

This tasty recipe was sponsored by McCormick – thanks for letting me work with the brands I love! 

Share The Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Love it! This looks super simple and delicious. I would love to try it with a portabello mushroom instead of chicken for a veggie option.

Oh Tiffany, this sandwich looks & sounds ‘scrumptious’! I’m sure it would be a HUGE HIT at any cookout, or as a quick & easy supper (on the grill) for any family (with a couple of easy ‘sides’). We love Bleu Cheese here, and also chicken….so this ‘awesome’ sandwich is one which we’ll definitely make very soon. I might have previously mentioned this…. that I LOVE your chicken recipes! The dishes which I’ve made and served from your blog were always a large hit with my family, and also with the dinner guests – to whom I served your dishes. Thanks Tiffany, since you always make me look like an experienced ‘Chef’ (which I’m definitely not), so I thank you for that.

Discover New Recipes