Three Cheese Macaroni Stuffed Peppers

The old classic macaroni gets a makeover in this Three Cheese Macaroni Stuffed Peppers version! 

Three Cheese Macaroni Stuffed Peppers

I’ve been in a pasta mega-mood lately. I’ve made it three times in the past four days, hence the qualification for mega-mood. I think it’s the cooler weather that does this. Is there a part of your brain that senses the weather changes and adjusts your food cravings accordingly? I took anatomy in college so I should probably know this, but a weather-food-a-thalamus isn’t really ringing any bells.

Three Cheese Macaroni Stuffed Peppers

Three Cheese Macaroni Stuffed Peppers

Three Cheese Macaroni Stuffed Peppers

In know that old school mac n’ cheese is a tough act to beat but you know what’s better than one straight up macaroni and cheese? Three cheese macaroni. Stuffed inside a roasted bell pepper. Ohhhhyeahhhhh.  Look at it – all stringy and gorgeous. Ah man, I seriously have a giant cheese crush.

Three Cheese Macaroni Stuffed Peppers

When I married my husband he was very much a meat and potatoes guy. His taste has evolved a lot since I’ve been food blogging and making hundreds of new recipes, but I still occasionally get nervous when I fix something he probably wouldn’t have cared for a few years ago. Namely, vegetarian dishes. This macaroni does’n’t have a shred of meat – not even bacon – so like I said, I was a hair-bit nervous. But he loved it. Seriously, l.o.v.e.d. it! That’s when you know a dish is good. It doesn’t contain meat and your meat-loving spouse can’t get enough of it.

I’m convinced it’s the cheese trio. That’ll win anyone over.

Three Cheese Macaroni Stuffed Peppers

Three Cheese Macaroni Stuffed Peppers

The old classic macaroni gets a makeover in this three-cheese version!
Course Main Course
Keyword macaroni, stuffed peppers
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 25 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Servings 4
Author Tiffany


  • 12 ounces dry elbow macaroni (NOT instant mac n' cheese)
  • 1 1/4 cups gruyere cheese, shredded
  • 1 cup sharp cheddar cheese, shredded
  • 1 cup white cheddar cheese, shredded + 1/2 cup, divided
  • 1 cup heavy cream (or half & half, or other milk)
  • 1 teaspoon salt, or to taste
  • 1/2 teaspoon black pepper, or to taste
  • 4 bell peppers (your color of choice)
  • chopped parlsey, to garnish


  • Preheat oven to 400. Cook macaroni noodles according to package instructions, then drain.
  • Add macaroni, cheeses (except for 1/2 cup white cheddar), heavy cream (or other milk) and stir over medium heat until cheeses are melted. Stir in salt and pepper.
  • Chop the tops of the peppers off and scoop out the seeds. Fill pepper with cheesy macaroni. Top with remaining shredded white cheddar cheese. Bake for about 10-15 minutes until cheese is melted. Sprinkle with chopped parsley if desired, serve warm.


Share The Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


oohh I like this!!!

Cold weather totally makes me crave cheesy carbs! I love that you baked the mac and cheese in the peppers, two comfort foods in one, love it!

Tiffany, This is one of my very FAVORITE Blogs. I pin just about every recipe. Love them all (but dislike fish), all of the rest are wonderful. Thanks, but I would not change a thing, don’t mess with the best! Thank you

    Hi Janelle! I’m sorry this reply is pretty delayed, Thanksgiving and Christmas got my blog wayyyy backed up with comments and questions about recipes for the holidays but I’m trying to get all caught up! thank you so much for your sweet comment! It’s a joy to know that you are enjoying my blog and finding great recipes to enjoy at home! Hope you’re having a great start to your new year! 🙂

This looks amazing. I want some right now with dinner. 🙂 My hubby is a meat and potatoes kinda of guy too. I’m gonna try to sneak this into our weekly rotation. Wish me luck, hehe. Pinned!

    Ooh, good luck!! I hope he loves it as much as my husband did! 🙂

It definitely must be the weather. The amount of carbs I’ve been craving is insane. I love that you stuffed the macaroni inside of peppers. It’s a nice change of pace.

    Thanks Karissa! I think it’s good to switch things up every now and then – especially with something that can tend to get kind of boring like macaroni!

If I wanted to make this but use it as a freezer meal what would you suggest doing differently?

This looks fab. I’m wondering if you could sub quinoa for the elbow noodles (or do half/half elbow noodles/quinoa) to cut back the pasta carbs a bit? Thoughts? Not sure how quinoa would cook up in the cheese mixture..

    Subbing quinoa should work great!!

      Happy to report! I did 1/2 cup quinoa and 6 oz of elbow noodles, also added cubed cooked chicken to get some protein in there. Simply AMAZING dish!!! Love this one.

        Okay it’s settled, I’m definitely going to have to try this with half quinoa because that sounds incredible! And my husband will be all. over. that chicken addition – he loves his meat!!

Looks amazing!! Is there any way to sub plain cream cheese for some of the cheese? Thanks!!

    Hi Elaine, you could probably sub in some cream cheese – the flavor will be different but that’s not necessarily a bad thing!

Discover New Recipes